Dallas Stars’ Pete DeBoer’s Feedback on Jake Oettinger Had been Off-Base – The Hockey Writers –

Lower than eight minutes into the Dallas Stars‘ do-or-die Recreation 5 matchup with the Edmonton Oilers, beginning goaltender Jake Oettinger was yanked from the crease. With head coach Pete DeBoer‘s staff getting ready to elimination, he sought a change—permitting two objectives on two pictures wasn’t slicing it for him.

You would say the choice itself backfired. Jeff Skinner scored lower than a minute after Oettinger’s departure en path to a 6–3 victory. But it surely’s DeBoer’s postgame press convention that was really jarring.

Courtesy of The Athletic‘s Mark Lazerus, DeBoer mentioned about his goaltender, “I didn’t blame all of it on Jake, however the actuality is if you happen to return to final 12 months’s playoffs, he’s misplaced six of [his last] seven video games to Edmonton. And we hand over two objectives on two pictures in an elimination recreation. […] That’s a reasonably large pattern dimension.”

DeBoer: “I did not blame all of it on Jake, however the actuality is if you happen to return to final 12 months’s playoffs, he is misplaced six of seven video games to Edmonton. And we hand over two objectives on two pictures in an elimination recreation. … That is a reasonably large pattern dimension.”

— Mark Lazerus (@MarkLazerus) May 30, 2025

Throwing Oettinger beneath the bus like this might be fairly problematic, all issues thought-about. He gained’t be a free agent till the summer season of 2033 and carries an annual cap hit of $8.25 million—this can be a crucial participant.

Associated: Oettinger and Stars Accomplished? Plus Extra NHL Information & Rumors

Was DeBoer’s outburst meant to justify pulling his franchise goaltender, and nothing else? Or, does it reveal waning confidence within the man between the pipes? In the end, he’s fallacious both method—the feedback had been off-base.

How Do Goalies Carry out In opposition to the Oilers within the Playoffs?

Since DeBoer referred again to the 2024 Playoffs, let’s have a look at how all goalies have carried out in opposition to Edmonton in that time-frame. Is perceived poor play an Oettinger-exclusive problem, or one thing that applies to everybody?

There have been six netminders with at the least three begins in opposition to the Oilers within the final two playoff campaigns. Listed here are their numbers, with “objectives saved above anticipated” courtesy of Evolving-Hockey:

DeBoer talked about Oettinger’s unlucky begin to Recreation 5 because the breaking level. In actuality, it took him from first to second place in objectives saved above anticipated. It’s not a be-all, end-all measurement for goalie efficiency, however it offers a good suggestion. If there was anybody to scapegoat for the Stars’ third straight defeat within the Western Convention Last, look to the protection. Oettinger did his half.

Oettinger Has Been the Answer, Not the Drawback

Regardless of what their win-loss file will let you know, the Stars weren’t taking part in nice hockey following Miro Heiskanen’s regular season-ending knee injury on Jan. 28. Based mostly on each the attention and stats check, the staff oftentimes struggled to exit their zone. Elite ending and goaltending hid regarding underlying numbers.

Over their subsequent 27 video games following the Heiskanen damage, Dallas was useless final in anticipated objectives in opposition to. Nevertheless, they had been 10^th in precise objectives in opposition to, made doable by the league’s second-best save share throughout these 27 video games. The most effective taking pictures share, too, allowed them to go 18–5–4.

Included in that span, nonetheless, was a two-game dropping streak in Video games 26 and 27. That spiraled right into a seven-game dropping streak to finish the season. An unsustainable taking pictures share and luxurious goaltending from each Oettinger and backup Casey DeSmith had been not hiding the reality. That pattern continued in opposition to the Oilers.

First, let’s speak in regards to the Stars’ right-shot defensemen. A core of Cody Ceci, Ilya Lyubushkin, Matt Dumba, and Alex Petrovic is definitely not Stanley Cup-caliber on paper. It wasn’t on the ice, both—the staff acquired out-chanced considerably when all however Petrovic came to visit the boards. The primary three price a mixed $10.25 million on the cap, but contributed extra to Dallas’ downfall than their success.

Regardless of signing a two-year, $7.5 million contract within the 2024 offseason, Dumba was a wholesome scratch all through the playoffs. Lyubushkin and Ceci, acquired in the identical offseason and subsequent trade deadline, acquired to play, however the Stars had been higher off after they didn’t.

These identical underlyings existed within the common season, besides the staff’s precise objectives share was superb. Ending and goaltending returned to extra affordable ranges within the postseason, so the staff sank.

It’s not like these outcomes had been unpredictable, both. Ceci, Lyubushkin, and Dumba had been questionable acquisitions on the time, they usually stay that right this moment. Defensemen don’t simply defend—they need to get out of the zone, but in addition transfer the puck up the ice to create offense. Oftentimes, these three did neither. Surviving was the secret.

But when the Stars’ protection was such a legal responsibility, how did they make the Western Convention Last to start with? That’s the place we get into their broader staff philosophy.

Dallas wins within the playoffs via construction and, when that fails, star gamers breaking out. In 2024, the staff was a well-oiled machine in opposition to the Vegas Golden Knights and Colorado Avalanche within the first two rounds. However the Oilers had been simply too dynamic to beat—construction faltered, and no one had a breakout collection. In the meantime, Connor McDavid had 10 factors in six video games.

In 2025, Mikko Rantanen’s 11 factors between Video games 5 and seven in opposition to the Avalanche buoyed the Stars to the second spherical. Construction failed at occasions, partially as a consequence of a weaker protection, however their newly added superstar had the stretch of his life. The Winnipeg Jets had their very own structural points in Spherical 2, whereas the Stars had been extra balanced, so the latter superior. The Oilers posed the identical problem as 2024—Edmonton’s superstars blossomed, resulting in Dallas’ construction falling aside disastrously.

The Stars’ playoff elimination was considerably inevitable. With a flawed roster, they had been roughly relying on continued Rantanen-type explosions to have any probability. That’s not Oettinger’s fault—criticizing him is redirecting blame from the place it actually belongs: the staff’s development.

This doesn’t imply that Dallas’ basis can not win a Stanley Cup. Somewhat, they have to be extra savvy of their additions. Their core, which incorporates Oettinger, is excellent—they have to be smarter in constructing round it. Adjustments shall be wanted in the summertime.

Stats courtesy of Natural Stat Trick, until specified in any other case